Why Communication Skills Dont Work In Customer Service


Every time my firm conducts communication skills training, we know someone is going to object.

"That doesn't work. Everybody's heard of active listening. You can't use that stuff anymore."

And we have to admit, there's a lot of truth in that. Everyone has heard of active listening. And it doesn't work for many people much of the time.

But communication skills can work for your staff.

The problem usually isn't the skills. It's the way people are trained to use them. Learn to use communication skills effectively, and they can create happy customers and higher income.

There are two components to good communication skills: (a) the skills themselves, and (b) what you're trying to do (your intention) when you use them. Many employees learn communication skills from manuals. And many manuals emphasize either skills, or intention but not both. And so, much of what we think of as communication skills training fails.

Here are a couple of examples:

Example 1: How active listening gets a black eye: using good skills, but with the intention to fix or change a customer

I was coaching a hospital social worker through a confrontation with a mother who was terribly frightened. The social worker was doing his best to demonstrate active listening.

"OK, I get that you're upset. And you want to get out of here. And I want to help you. But you've got to go through this process before you can take your daughter home."

The mother didn't react at all the way he'd hoped. "I don't want to hear all this institutional talk," she said. "You leave me alone. I'll sue if I have to!"

This appears to be a failure of active listening. And it is, but the problem goes deeper than that. When I paused the encounter and asked the social worker how he thought the mother was feeling and what she needed, he said, "I don't really know. I was busy trying to get her to do what I wanted and think it was her idea."

Active listening skills are useful, but they're only tools. They serve the intentions of the person using them. And if you don't teach trainees useful intentions, most will fall back on trying to fix people or change them. So you'll be training your staff to be very effective at letting your customers know they need to be fixed or changed. And your customers will let you know how unpleasant an experience that is.

Example 2: How "understand before you are understood" fails: having a useful intention but lacking the skills to communicate it

I paused a training scenario just after an angry man blew up at a nurse. I was coaching the nurse through an encounter with a father who felt the staff was trying to hustle him and his son out of the hospital.

He told her that he worked all day and came into the hospital all night. And where did she think he was going to get the time to go through training before he took his son home?

When I asked her how she thought the man was feeling and what he needed, she suggested that he seemed overwhelmed and afraid, and that he might need some support.

When I suggested she might ask the man if that's what he was experiencing, she turned to him and said, "You need an appointment with a social worker. I'll set something up for you."

This is a classic failure that comes from understanding your customer, but lacking the skills to communicate it. The nurse could describe the source of the man's anger clearly to me. She had real empathy for him. But she couldn't put her words together in a way he recognized as compassionate.

We'd taught her the words, of course. But like most people who learn new skills, she lacked the confidence to use them. So she, like the trainee above, fell back on trying to fix the customer. And he let her know how much he disliked being treated that way.

It don't mean a thing if you ain't practicing

Both of the examples above underscore a third important component of communication skills training, namely, the practice.

The trainee in the first example was a compassionate man with a degree in social work. I'm sure he'd had ample exposure to good communication skills. It had never gelled for him before.

Once we put him in a scenario, coached him through the skills, and alerted him to the fact that he was struggling because he was trying to fix his customer instead of connecting with her (that's the intention we teach), he developed skills rapidly. He even returned to training weeks later to report that he'd created a real difference in his life using the skills at home. He quickly became a valued mentor to others in his work group.

Communication skills are deceptively challenging. It takes no great intellect or dexterity to utter the words. What is terribly demanding is all the processing: keeping your focus on the other person despite your own discomfort, listening for the needs beneath complaints and accusations, drumming up the nerve to suggest to an outraged man that he might value some support.

What gets you through tough interactions is your confidence in your own intention and skills. And you learn confidence through practice.

In my experience, those are the keys to effective communication skills:

1. holding a useful intention like understanding the other person or connecting with them,

2. employing skills that communicate your intention, and

3. practicing the skills and intentions so you have them at hand, even when interactions get intense, especially when they do.

Find training that will provide you all three, and you'll have communication skills that will please your customers and increase your income.

Tim Dawes is the founder of Interplay, Inc., a firm that helps healthcare organizations to exceed their strategic goals by demonstrating unexpected empathy to patients. Learn about a step-by-step process that helps your staff make their natural compassion more deliberate and consistent for patients, and sign up for monthly "how to" articles at http://www.interplaygroup.com/pages/free_resources.html







Related News



Customer Service: Old Technology is Often the Best - Wall Street Journal Blogs

Wall Street Journal Blogs

Customer Service: Old Technology is Often the Best
Wall Street Journal Blogs, NY -8 hours ago
People are more likely than ever to spread the word after a bad customer-service experience. That’s according to a new survey of more than 2000 consumers ...

Gregg & Valby Unveils Mortgage Fulfillment Solutions for Banks - MarketWatch

Gregg & Valby Unveils Mortgage Fulfillment Solutions for Banks
MarketWatch -4 hours ago
Well-defined customer service levels must be established. Frequent reporting must be required, and service levels must be measured on an ongoing basis. ...

How Can I Train My Staff on My Customer Service Policy? - New York Times

How Can I Train My Staff on My Customer Service Policy?
New York Times, United States -13 hours ago
By AllBusiness.com Your customer service policy is only as good as the employees who carry it out. For that reason, it's very important to train them on how ...

Going Green for the Holidays - MarketWatch

Going Green for the Holidays
MarketWatch -9 hours ago
The ecoNEW program is an innovative, online electronics trade-in service operated by NEW Customer Service Companies, Inc. to support its retail partners. ...

Aria Systems Celebrates Fifth Anniversary With Record Third ... - MarketWatch

Aria Systems Celebrates Fifth Anniversary With Record Third ...
MarketWatch -3 hours ago
Exemplifying Aria's focus on continuing to improve the quality of the overall customer experience, investments in account management and customer service...
Amdocs Signs Six-Year Managed Services Contract with MetroPCSTMC Net
MetroPCS Cites Subscriber GrowthWireless Week
MetroPCS takes Amdocs solutionMobile Entertainment
TMCnet - PR Newswire (press release)
all 20 news articles

Radiant Systems and Petro-Canada Team Up to Bring Self-Service ... - MarketWatch

Radiant Systems and Petro-Canada Team Up to Bring Self-Service...
MarketWatch -3 hours ago
Properly designed and implemented self-service solutions are proven to improve the speed of customer service, increase up-sells, and help ensure order ...

Imports Customer Service Assistant - New Zealand Herald

Imports Customer Service Assistant
New Zealand Herald, New Zealand -8 hours ago
Join a large multi national company and take your Import Customer Service career to the next level? This well known company is looking for an ideal ...

Southern California Companies Rapidly Adopting Airband's WiMAX ... - MarketWatch

Southern California Companies Rapidly Adopting Airband's WiMAX ...
MarketWatch -2 hours ago
Superb Customer Service: Airband provides 24/7 monitoring and support to ensure that any issues are resolved before they impact customers' business, ...


Customer-Service Chat Has Pros, Cons for Health Plans - NewsFactor Network

Customer-Service Chat Has Pros, Cons for Health Plans
NewsFactor Network, CA -3 hours ago
Software provider Connextions recommends an agent use pre-programmed chat messages such as: "Your customer service agent is researching your question and ...

Contact Solutions Announces Columbia Bank Chooses Its Shared IVR ... - MarketWatch

Contact Solutions Announces Columbia Bank Chooses Its Shared IVR ...
MarketWatch -5 hours ago
"Our focus has always been on fundamental banking and strong customer service. Outsourcing key customer service functions to Contact Solutions, ...